2-Story Moment Frame with Panel Zones and RBS Result

[baikunthasilwal]

I found the different time period and floor displacement response when I check the following website to perform dynamic analysis for two story moment resisting frame with panel zones.

http://opensees.berkeley.edu/wiki/index ... es_and_RBS

First, the time period of the frame is T1=0.00098823 and T2=0.0009789, which are drastically different from the posted results (T1 = 0.81 s and T2 = 0.18 s). Please clarify about this issue.

Next, the displacement response is also significantly different. The analysis shows that the displacement response is 0.138 in and 0.199 in for second floor and third floor.However, the published result in the website are 3 in and 6 in for these floors respectively.

I am curious to know why the response for the frame with panel zones differs significantly compared with the frame without the panel zone. Does the properties of panel zone change the response significantly or is there any other issue that influence the response of the frame?

I am looking forward to receive the response so that the results for time period and displacement response will be acceptable.

[fmk]

the difference is due to the new and improved! "Bilin" material .. i am looking at providing the ability to use the old material as a number of people have problems with the new and improved one .. it will be in the new release, out later this week or next.

[gudipati]

I also encountered the same problem as Mr. Bainkuntha Silwal. By looking at the mode shapes using DisplayModel2D.tcl, it appears that the first two modes correspond to local panel zone modes and not the actual building mode.
A similar model using bilin material but without panel zones gives the time period T1=0.82s and T2=0.2s (http://opensees.berkeley.edu/wiki/index ... ment_Frame).

Could someone please confirm if the actual cause of discrepancy is not the bilin material but the above stated reason?

Thanks,
Vamshi Krishna

[writemyessay]

My Essay Writer is the go-to source for the completion of academic assignments. If you are screaming out “Write my essay for me,”
https://www.myessaywriter.net
you’ve come to the most elite essay writing service.

[akiraroy]

IIIASA in jaipur gives the best IAS coaching with best available help and helps in guiding the student to the best.
Want to know the best ( https://latestnewsworldnews.blogspot.in ... labus.html ) IAS coaching institute jaipur?
Well It is IIIASA.

[actonmartin]

When you use your android device that time cache data automatically create and this process run every time so that that cache covers your mobile storage space. To get rid of this data you can use Phone Cleaner App for android mobile even you can remove these types of junk and boost your device in single click. Even you can read more about this from here https://www.itlapps.com/cleaner-app/phone-cleaner/

[sriarun]

I am facing the same issue.
I do understand that the local panel zone modes are activated for some reason.
Kindly let me know if this issue has been resolved.

Thanks,
Srinivasan A

[farhadsevom]

سکن کتاب های نایاب
اگر نتوانستید کتاب یا مجله یا حتی مقاله های خود را به صورت الکترونیکی یا چاپی تهیه کنید، می توانید این نوع منابع نایاب را داخل سایت فایلسو (Filesoo.com) درخواست دهید تا پس از بررسی، مدت زمان و هزینه تهیه اسکن کتاب خارجی به شما اطلاع داده شده و در مدت زمان مشخص شده برای شما تهیه و ارسال شود. این نوع کتاب های الکترونیکی به صورت فایل pdf بوده و تمام صفحات نیز تمام عکس خواهد بود،البته در اکثر فایل ها و کتاب لاتین ارسال شده قابلیت جستجو در متن وجود دارد.
سایت فایلسو http://filesoo.com/books/
Filesoo.com